Michigan School Shooting…. What Went Wrong?

Michigan School Shooting…. What Went Wrong?
By Lt. Joseph Pangaro

In many cases such as this terrible mass murder event, when we look back in the investigation phase, we see a cascading series of events that led to tragedy. In this case, like the Parkland High School shooting, we see that just about everything that could have gone wrong, did go wrong.

The parents have been charged criminally, the prosecutors have asserted that they had a responsibility in the events that led to the deaths of four students and the serious injuries of many others. And now we see the prosecutor is considering charging some of the school officials for their actions or inactions in the series of events that led to the deaths and injuries in the Oakland High School.

 As a person who teaches police officers and trains school personnel on safety and security issues, I find this lack of proper response on all parts is not uncommon. The difference is simply that these places have not had an active shooter rage through their hallways. If they had they would suffer similar or worse consequences.

My point here is not to point fingers or place blame, my goal is to sound the alarm, again, that we must all plan and prepare seriously to respond to violence because the next horrific school shooting is only weeks, days or moments away.

What I often hear from school official is what I have called the most dangerous thing we can ever say, that being: “It will never happen here.”

While the statistics are clear, most schools will never be victimized by an active shooter. There are between 10 and 20 active shooter events in the United States each year, 2021 has been an exception in that we have had a higher number of these incidents than in previous years. When we see that there are about 100,000 schools in the USA and 10 to 20 shooting events, the chance of being involved in any individual school is extremely low. But….

A question I ask at every event where I teach Active Shooter Response is this, “When and where will the next school shooting take place?”

I have been teaching this topic for 15 years and not one time has anyone raised their hand to tell me when and where the next shooting would erupt.They cannot because no one knows where that will happen. With that caveat, then the real odds of being involved in a school shooter are revealed as such: “It either happens at your school or it doesn’t. It’s really a 50-50 chance.” That changes the equation and should focus our attention on our preparation.        In a recent article, I wrote about the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on young people and adults as well. I pointed out that we are all experiencing a form of PTSD from the lockdowns and the concerns about getting sick and potentially dying as well as the concerns some people have about the vaccines and their effects. All of this has had a grinding affect on us mentally, our kids included. My concern, and the reason for the article, was to sound an alarm that as we come out of the pandemic there will be a potential for violence from people who might not have been a threat before the pandemic.

The increased number of shootings in schools in 2021, reported to be about 48 incidents so far, clearly points to that reality and backs up my concern. The active shooter event in Michigan has put a fine point on the warning and will hopefully act as an eye opener. The time to prepare is NOW.

So, it is great to sound a warning and call attention to a problem, but what exactly can schools, parents and the police do to prevent the next attack?

The simple answer is - there is a lot we can do. The problem is that too many police agencies, schools and parents fall back on the most dangerous thing we can ever say- “It will never happen here.” Unfortunately, the truth is: “It might happen here, and we have to be ready,” that is a responsibility we all have as a society.

Here are some things we need to do to prevent the next attack.

1. Understand the status of your school’s safety and security and ability to respond to an active shooter attack. You do that by getting a thorough “All Hazard Threat, Vulnerability, and Risk Assessment.” This is the first step in your security process. You can get one of these from a private company or from your local police. A consideration is the quality of the assessment. As a police officer, I conducted these, and I did as good a job as I could based on my training and the time I had allotted to it. I did not always have the amount of time to dedicate to the school as would be best so consider a private company. There is a cost, but it is well worth the money spent.

2. Run drills of value. If all you do is run pre-planned drills and check off boxes that indicate you practiced, you are not prepared. Drills have to be realistic to have value. Planning a drill of value can be difficult the first time, but once you do one the next ones are easy. Use role players to play the part of an assailant, invite the police, first aid teams and other responders to participate. I have a whole prepared list of activities to help you. Reach out to me if you are interested.

3. Get your staff trained to identify potentially dangerous students so they can intervene before violence erupts in your school. This training includes understanding what threats are; they include drawings, writings, kill lists, social media comments or posts and the staff needs to know how to respond to these threats.

4. Learn how to conduct proper in-school investigations. Use a “Uniformity of investigation” process so all of your school investigators conduct their investigations in a similar manner, use the same forms, and are trained equally.

5. Work with your local police and develop a relationship where the school and the police understand how to proceed when threats are identified, or an attack begins.

All of these things are a good start and will help you make your school safer, but the key is the All-Hazards Threat Assessment, this is the place to begin so you understand your strengths and weaknesses so you can create a road map for change which can include, policy, procedures, protocols, as well as budgeting for equipment and training.

Lt. Joseph Pangaro retired after serving 27 years at a police department in Monmouth County, NJ, having served as the Lead Training Officer. Pangaro is a graduate of Fairleigh Dickenson University’s Certified Public Managers Program (CPM). He’s a newspaper columnist who writes about the rigors and joys in law enforcement. Joseph Pangaro is the CEO and President of Pangaro Training and Management, and Pangaro Global Training, an online training company. E-mail at: JPangaro@TrueSecurityDesign.com, www.TrueSecurityDesign.com